Repair it if the sealed system is sound and the part is still made. A new refrigerator runs $900 to $2,600 installed, so most repairs under about $700 are the cheaper path, and compressor work at $700 to $1,800 is the one that usually tips it the other way.

First, name the fault. Not cooling is not enough, because the same symptom covers a $120 to $250 relay and $700 to $1,800 of sealed system work.
Second, ask whether the part is still made. If it is not, the decision is made for you.
Third, compare the repair against $900 to $2,600 installed. Not the shelf price. The shelf price plus delivery, plus hauling the old one out, plus any carpentry the opening needs.
Fourth, count the history. One repair is maintenance. Three in two years is a pattern, and the pattern is the argument for replacing.
Any job that opens the refrigerant circuit, the compressor included, runs $700 to $1,800 and needs a licensed tech. It is the one failure that tips this decision on its own. Short of that, a sound cabinet and a working compressor keep a refrigerator worth fixing far longer than most people assume.
The reverse is worth saying plainly. A machine that has already had one major part replaced and has now failed somewhere else is a fair place to stop spending.
Real, but slow. A new refrigerator does use less electricity. It rarely saves enough in a year to beat a repair that costs a fraction of a replacement, so treat it as a tiebreaker and not as a reason.
Waiting it out is the one option with a hidden cost. A refrigerator that cannot hold temperature throws away a load of groceries every week it stays that way, and two or three weeks of that costs more than a relay.
| Part | Typical range |
|---|---|
| Start relay or overload protectorOne of the two cheap failures worth ruling out first on a unit that is not cooling | $120 to $250 |
| Condenser or evaporator fan motorThe other one. A clicking every few minutes points here or at the relay | $150 to $350 |
| Defrost heater or thermostatHeavy frost on the back wall, or a unit that cools then warms | $180 to $400 |
| Thermistor or temperature sensorRunning constantly without reaching temperature | $130 to $280 |
| Door gasketVaries most by model; a built in gasket costs far more than a freestanding one | $150 to $400 |
| Electronic control boardThe modern cost driver. A mechanical predecessor was a fraction of this | $350 to $700 |
| Compressor or sealed systemThe one real cliff. Opening the refrigerant circuit is a different class of job and is quoted on its own | $700 to $1,800 |
For comparison, a replacement typically runs $900 to $2,600 installed, which is the figure to compare against rather than the shelf price.
Replace it when the expensive half failed: the compressor, the sealed system or the drum bearing. The price on the tag hides the rest of it: delivery, hauling the old one away, and any work the opening needs. Get somebody to look at it before you buy a new one.
Start with the sticker. It is usually easier to find than people expect. If the appliance lives in a basement, a garage or an outbuilding, say so. Where it sits changes both the diagnosis and the access. Call us and read the model number straight off the sticker.
Start with the power, the door switch and the filters. Those three explain a lot of dead appliances. The line is the panel. Behind it are live terminals, sharp edges and sealed refrigerant, and none of that is a first try job. When in doubt, unplug it and call.
The part decides the price, so the diagnosis comes before the figure.
(716) 414-5233